An Explanation for All These Controversial Scorecards

An Explanation for All These Controversial Scorecards

513

By: Ben Sutherland

Adalaide Byrd’s recent 118-110 scorecard at the Canelo v Golovkin fight was seemingly outrageous. It left many out there, including myself, pondering the legitimacy of the whole thing. More fuel was added to the fire at last weekend’s heavyweight title fight between Joseph Parker and Hughie Fury who were contesting the WBO world title. In what was a close fight which could have gone either way, Fury probably didn’t do quite enough to definitively dethrone Parker. However, as the scorecards were read out, another 118-110 card appeared in favor of Parker. Fury and his team were livid and spent the rest of the night speculating about corruption in the sport to any media outlet that would listen.


Photo Credit: USA Today

Thanks to fights like these, boxing fans have recently been become increasingly disillusioned and disenfranchised with a sport that seems to often be predetermined. However, what if there was a more innocent explanation?
Boxing is subjective. Some judges prefer better technical work and boxing ability whereas many other judges will look for work rate and punches thrown. In this way, it is possible for two separate judges to view a close in favor of a different fighter. On the assumption there are no knockdowns each round would be scored 10-9 to whichever fighter each judge selected.

Boxing scores do not leave space to account for how close each individual round was. In one round, a boxer can be punched around the ring, take heavy body shots, big uppercuts and spend the entire 3 minutes tucked up or staggering around the ring but provided they don’t hit the canvas, the round is 10-9. In another round, the contest could be incredibly close with both fighters throwing similar numbers of shots, landing similar numbers of shots and evading similar numbers of shots. However at the end of it, one fighter still wins the round 10-9. There is obviously a massive difference in these two rounds but this is just simply not reflected on the scorecards.

Let’s take this a step further. For this hypothetical I will use Parker and Fury as my fighters. In this hypothetical scenario, one judge marginally prefers technical boxing ability and the other has a slight inclination towards work rate. The first round could be ridiculously close and the two judges in question could give the round to a different fighter. So after round one, one scorecard has Parker up 10-9 and on another Fury is up 10-9. If the second round is also very close, there is no logical reason why the judge would give the round to the other fighter this time. Perhaps he could worry that his scorecard might not reflect how close the fight is and give the round to the other fighter for this reason. However, it would be professionally dishonest for the judge to give the round to the other fighter simply because he was fearful of controversy. If the fight carries on playing out in this close fashion, the judge would carry on giving the rounds to the fighter he prefers by a miniscule margin. If we extrapolate this over the course of 12 rounds, it is therefore possible for our unbelievably close fight to be scored 120-108 to Parker by one judge and 120-108 to Fury by the other judge.

Any assumption that a close fight should be scored 114-114 is simply illogical. This type of thinking reflects the flawed logic in what is known as the gamblers fallacy. This is the idea that because you flip a coin once and it lands on heads, it is more likely to land on tails the next time. In reality, the chance of landing a tail the next throw is identical to the first throw – 1 in 2. The parameters of each throw have not changed and the fact that the coin landed on heads the first time does not change the coin in any way and so it is no more likely to land on tails the next time.

This same logic applies to boxing. Just because Parker scraped the first round by the skin of his teeth does not mean that if the next round is really close that it should be given to Fury.

Perhaps then, both the Canelo v GGG and Parker v Fury scorecards were symptomatic of a close fight. It just seems very difficult to reflect that in the scoring system. Whilst a 10-10 round is a possibility, it is used infrequently both official scorecards and TV scorecards. Perhaps it is time to get a bit more trigger happy with it?

Tags:

513 Comments

  1. Michaellum
    03/10/2025,

    I’ve been taking cornbread hemp sleep gummies concerning a while instantly, and they’ve creditably been a game-changer as regards force and sleep. The pre-eminent part? No grogginess in the morning impartial a balmy, composed sensation up front bed. Plus, they have knowledge of tickety-boo, opposite from some other supplements I’ve tried. I was skeptical at beginning, but after day by day using them, I can decidedly translate they help with unwinding after a sustained day. If you’re looking representing a reasonable practice to chill without any preternatural side effects, CBD gummies are benefit trying. Just make sure you get a importance stamp with third-party testing!

  3. LorenzoPhoft
    03/18/2025,

    They bridge the gap between countries with their service.
    cytotec cost
    Their international health campaigns are revolutionary.

  65. Michaelheago
    03/31/2025,

    Kamagra Gel: kamagra – Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept

  116. LanceWaisk
    04/06/2025,

    can i buy generic clomid without a prescription: Clom Fast Pharm – where buy cheap clomid no prescription

  129. BradyAduck
    04/09/2025,

    gГјvenilir deneme bonusu veren siteler: casino siteleri – guvenilir casino siteleri casinositeleri1st.com

  133. Robertglarp
    04/09/2025,

    casino siteleri 2025: casino siteleri – lisansl? casino siteleri casinositeleri1st.com

  143. Garretttoomi
    04/10/2025,

    deneme bonusu site casibom 1st en iyi bahis sitesi hangisi casibom1st.shop

  150. Robertglarp
    04/11/2025,

    online kumar siteleri: casibom giris – en iyi casino sitesi casibom1st.com

  156. Cletuskak
    04/12/2025,

    mexican drugstore online: USMexPharm – medicine in mexico pharmacies

  160. Dennisbiarm
    04/13/2025,

    usa mexico pharmacy: USMexPharm – certified Mexican pharmacy

  224. VictorDeers
    04/21/2025,

    olympe casino en ligne: olympe – olympe

  239. Bernardactit
    04/25/2025,

    Achat Cialis en ligne fiable: cialis generique – Cialis sans ordonnance 24h tadalmed.shop

  241. Bernardactit
    04/25/2025,

    Tadalafil sans ordonnance en ligne: Cialis en ligne – Cialis generique prix tadalmed.shop

  252. Bernardactit
    04/26/2025,

    Pharmacie en ligne Cialis sans ordonnance: Cialis en ligne – Cialis generique prix tadalmed.shop

  253. BillieRef
    04/26/2025,

    Achat Cialis en ligne fiable: cialis prix – cialis generique tadalmed.shop

  256. Bernardactit
    04/26/2025,

    pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique: pharmacie en ligne – Pharmacie sans ordonnance pharmafst.com

  258. Bernardactit
    04/26/2025,

    cialis generique: cialis prix – Achat Cialis en ligne fiable tadalmed.shop

  260. Bradleyeages
    04/26/2025,

    pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne – vente de mГ©dicament en ligne pharmafst.com

  294. ElmerDaw
    04/30/2025,

    pin up azerbaycan: pin-up – pin-up casino giris

  307. Brianthigo
    05/01/2025,

    вавада зеркало: vavada – vavada вход

  342. ElmerDaw
    05/05/2025,

    вавада официальный сайт: vavada – vavada casino

  395. JudsonVum
    05/12/2025,

    clomid tablets: Clom Health – where to buy generic clomid without prescription

  403. Oscardaf
    05/12/2025,

    can i get clomid without dr prescription: Clom Health – buying generic clomid no prescription

  409. JudsonVum
    05/12/2025,

    cost of cheap clomid tablets: Clom Health – buy generic clomid prices

  416. Oscardaf
    05/13/2025,

    can you buy prednisone online uk: PredniHealth – how much is prednisone 10 mg

  422. MatthewHacle
    05/13/2025,

    can i purchase generic clomid prices Clom Health can i order generic clomid for sale

  427. LorenBonee
    05/14/2025,

    cialis a domicilio new jersey: TadalAccess – best price for tadalafil

  434. JosephLaf
    05/15/2025,

    how long does it take for cialis to start working TadalAccess tadalafil online paypal

  436. LorenBonee
    05/15/2025,

    tadalafil dose for erectile dysfunction: TadalAccess – is tadalafil and cialis the same thing?

  441. Jerrysoype
    05/16/2025,

    At from the start, I was skeptical in the matter of https://joyorganics.com/products/cbd-dog-treats , but sometimes I provide for them in my nightstand. They’ve evolve into participation of my evening habitual—one gummy, a cup of tea, and I’m chaste to go. I don’t feel exorbitant or weird, nothing but calm and cordial to twaddle down. The flavor’s in truth exceptionally well-behaved too, which surprised me. No unnatural aftertaste like some others I’ve tried. If your imagination runs a mile a tick at cimmerian dark or you’re honest tough to relax after farm, these are undoubtedly worth checking out.

  444. LorenBonee
    05/16/2025,

    cialis 20 mg best price: TadalAccess – blue sky peptide tadalafil review

  448. ScottCug
    05/17/2025,

    is cialis a controlled substance: TadalAccess – buy cialis with american express

  449. LorenBonee
    05/17/2025,

    how to get cialis without doctor: TadalAccess – cialis once a day

  464. JosephLaf
    05/19/2025,

    where to buy cialis over the counter [url=https://tadalaccess.com/#]Tadal Access[/url] is tadalafil the same as cialis

  465. ScottCug
    05/19/2025,

    canadian pharmacy cialis 40 mg: TadalAccess – buy cialis online overnight shipping

  466. LorenBonee
    05/19/2025,

    cialis discount coupons: Tadal Access – is generic tadalafil as good as cialis

  494. JosephMom
    05/27/2025,

    buying erectile dysfunction pills online: ed rx online – Ero Pharm Fast

  510. pmonvrduu
    06/02/2025,

    Play live with real players from around the world, anytime, anywhere in a language of your choice. Lightning Dragon Tiger In Softonic we scan all the files hosted on our platform to assess and avoid any potential harm for your device. Our team performs checks each time a new file is uploaded and periodically reviews files to confirm or update their status. This comprehensive process allows us to set a status for any downloadable file as follows: Take your Mobile card game love to the next level with Rummy APK. Download the RummyAres application today and enjoy the best gaming experience on this online rummy. Whether you want to have fun with friends or hone your skills, this game delivers an unforgettable experience. The ONORC scheme is implemented for the Nation-Wide portability of ration cards under National Food Security Act (NFSA). Through this, all eligible ration card holders beneficiaries covered under NFSA can utilize their entitlements from anywhere in the country.
    https://visitcentraljava.com/bonus-structures-in-aviator-casinos-canadian-overview/uncategorized/
    Colourful live slot bursting with multipliers and a live Balloon Race Bonus game! The friendly match lasts for one minute and comprises a maximum of 20 questions. The player who solves faster wins and can claim the points. The learning app offers a simple way to boost your mental math skills with little monetary incentives, which you can withdraw. Since it runs on an ad-based model, an overwhelming amount of advertisements is expected. Play different eSports games available for betting on the Betwinner app for Android. These include such popular titles such as Dota 2, League of Legends, CS 2, and StarCraft 2. Colourful live slot bursting with multipliers and a live Balloon Race Bonus game! Immerse your players in our latest IGT UNITE™ Treasure Editions, featuring 10 top-performing games including the famous Magic Treasures™ Multi-Level Progressives.

  511. zpvdqneoi
    06/11/2025,

    O app Lucky Jet móvel vem com a mesma funcionalidade e opções disponíveis no site de apostas 1win. Isso significa que você pode ganhar dinheiro real jogando Lucky Jet no app móvel 1win. Cassinos online possuem uma interface intuitiva e lucky bet apostas fácil de usar. Todas as apostas são divididas em 3 categorias principais: Simples (chance única e dupla) – o tipo mais simples de aposta. O Play 1win Lucky Jet oferece apostas automáticas e recursos de saque automático que permitem aos usuários gerenciar suas apostas e finanças de forma eficiente. Essas opções são muito populares entre os jogadores do Lucky Jet 1win, pois facilitam muito o processo de jogar o jogo. O Lucky Jet APP também está disponível em dispositivos iOS. Nosso aplicativo é otimizado para iOS, garantindo uma experiência divertida para usuários de iPhone e iPad. O aplicativo aproveita ao máximo os recursos e elementos de design específicos do iOS, fornecendo uma interface suave e responsiva.
    https://professionalglasswindowstinting.com/sweet-bonanza-mecanicas-inteligentes-e-visual-encantador-para-jogadores-brasileiros/
    Normalmente as apostas de JetX tem um valor mínimo para poder participar e não permitirá apostas abaixo do estipulado. No entanto, você provavelmente seguirá jogar tranquilamente se fizer o depósito mínimo da casa de apostas que oferece o jogo. Desde que o Jetx, muito conhecido como “jogo do foguetinho”, foi lançado, muitos se perguntam as formas de ganhar dinheiro com esta opção. Existem várias plataformas confiáveis onde você pode jogar o JetX com segurança e lucratividade. Alguns deles incluem o Blaze, KTO, CBet, Pin Up, 1Win, Parimatch e 1XBet. Para exemplificar, veja como fazer uma aposta no JetX na Parimatch, o processo é o mesmo para todas as casas indicadas neste artigo: рџЋҐ Veja mais: assista ao vídeo abaixo e aprenda a localizar carros raros no GTA 5 A emoção do JetX é saber exatamente a hora certa de “retirar a mão”, antes que o foguete exploda e você perca a sua aposta.

  512. cmhemlyta
    06/15/2025,

    Ceasuri de dama Jocul Lucky Jet game 1 win — este un slot crash onest unde utilizatorii pot obține câștiguri mari în câteva minute. Jucătorii trebuie să plaseze un pariu la începutul rundei și să reușească să își retragă câștigurile înainte ca personajul Lucky Joe să dispară de pe ecran. Mai jos am subliniat principalele caracteristici ale jocului 1win Lucky Jet game. Two years after the Russian attack on the entire Ukraine, book author Ciocan hopes his novel remains dystopian. “When I think of the Ukrainians, we Moldovans were lucky,” he says. But it’s too early to breathe a sigh of relief. This has been CNBC’s live blog covering updates on the war in Ukraine. După înregistrarea în aplicația 1Win, poate doriți să depuneți bani în contul dvs. pentru a începe să pariați sau să jucați jocuri de cazino. Aplicația oferă diferite metode de depunere pentru a se potrivi diferitelor preferințe ale utilizatorilor. Iată pașii generali pentru a depune bani în aplicația 1Win:
    http://classiccarsales.ie/author/dearlivefill1987/
    Utilizați acest formular pentru a lăsa feedback cu privire la produs sau pentru a pune o întrebare Utilizați acest formular pentru a lăsa feedback cu privire la produs sau pentru a pune o întrebare – Conexiunea internet prin care aparatul este conectat la serverul central al furnizorului de software unde se realizează și se accepta validează biletul tichetul de pariere. teramed.ro These lifelike miniatures of iconic landmarks can be found on the Panorama — which, at 9,335 square feet, is the largest model of New York City, meticulously hand-built at a scale of 1:1,200. The sprawling model sits in its own room at the Queens Museum, where it was first installed in the 1960s, softly rotating between day and night lighting as visitors on glass walkways are given a bird’s eye view of all five boroughs of the city.

  513. comexayaa
    06/16/2025,

    WhatsApp: Click here 76790688 Content Bonus Dla Nowych Klientów W Aplikacji Mostbet Mostbet Pl Dla Androida Jak Wygląda Proces Pobierania I Instalacji Na Androida? Wersja Mobilna Strony Internetowej Mostbet Czym Różni Się Aplikacja Mostbet Od Wersji Mobilnej? Jak Obstawiać Zakłady Ekspresowe W Aplikacji Mostbet? Instalowanie Aplikacji Na Telefonie Z … WhatsApp: Click here 76790688 There are many benefits to to be a Russian girl. Besides natural beauty and faithfulness, Russian women are usually devoted and will do everything to keep their very own man content. Unlike developed ladies, Russian women are also devoted to their appearance. Therefore , it is vital for a gentleman to never interfere with this kind of aspect of the life. ContentWhy I Acquired TWO Mostbet app Casino App For My ChildrenKim Kardashian …
    https://www.vanilla.in.th/member.cgi?mid=1749927156
    The event began with a press conference with the participation of President of the Institute of National Remembrance, Karol Nawrocki, PhD. Then an immersive game projection began, during which participants could enter the world of the war past and feel the realistic atmosphere of “Aviators”. Podziel się swoją opinią z innymi Klientami © www2.carapicuiba.sp.gov.br Wskaźnik intensywności zabudowy jak go obliczyć Garmin Forerunner 265 Zasady ochrony prywatności mogą się różnić, np. w zależności od używanych funkcji lub Twojego wieku. Więcej informacji Listę sklepów publikujemy tutaj: Jakie sklepy w Galerii Navigator Na budowę zegarka sportowego Garmin D2™ Mach 1 Aviator 010-02582-55 składają się: Call To Order Więcej informacji na Facebooku. Czym jeźdżę (motocykl)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *