Legal Analysis: Beibut Shumenov v Goossen Tutor, Breach of Contract

Legal Analysis: Beibut Shumenov v Goossen Tutor, Breach of Contract

767

By Bryanna Fissori

Breach of Contract, Fiduciary Duty and Fraud. . . Beibut Shumenov v Goossen Tutor Promotions

“Is it really over?” That’s the question Light Heavyweight Champion Beibut Shumenov is asking the Clark County, Nevada District Court to answer. On March 17, 2011 Shumenov filed a lawsuit against Goossen Tutor Promotions (GTP) alleging three causes of action; breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty and fraud and deceptive trade practices.

The contract was set to extend for three years from May 15, 2010 and required GTP to promote a minimum of two bouts per year. As of January 2011, Shumenov considered the agreement with GTP terminated due to the causes of action asserted, but without court confirmation the promotions company may be able to turn the tables and go after Shumenov for contract breach.

Shumenov also owns promotional company, KZ Event Productions, with his brother Chingis. According to the claim filed Shumenov had been doing his own promotions as well and wanted to be able to focus on his training. He also wanted to establish a relationship with a third party promoter who had television contracts and industry knowledge. The two enterprises worked together on Shumenov’s last two bouts.

The first bout was in July of 2010 against Vyacheslav Uzelkov, which Shumenov won by unanimous decision to defend his belt. The bout took place at Tachi Palace in Lemoore, California. This was a significantly smaller venue than Shumenov’s bouts recently preceding and according to Section 18 of the general allegations of the complaint (complaint), GTP did not inform Shumenov that the venue was outdoors until after it was finalized. Temperatures in Lemoore during the summer easily exceed 100 degrees. The complaint also alleges that terms of the contract expressly required Shumenov to pay the purse for this specific bout, but according to Section 20 of the complaint, GTP “reported to the California Boxing Commission and the IBA and WBA that GTP would pay Shumenov a $200,000 purse for the fight. This was untrue. . .” Nothing was paid by GTP and Shumenov also paid $14,000 in taxes on the phantom purse to GTP, which was allegedly not received by the State of California.

The second bout with GTP on board was January 8, 2011 against William Joppy, which Shumenov finished with a sixth round-round knockout. Joppy was a last minute stand in on the card for original opponent Juergen Braehmer, who supposedly fell ill a few days before the event. Shumenov had his eye on Braehmer since August of 2010 and requested GTP to set up the match for an HBO or Showtime broadcast. It was not until Shumenov offered again to pay the purse, that GTP made efforts toward procurement. The bout took place in Kazakhstan. According to Section 33 and 34 of the complaint GTP was supposed to have obtained $150,000 in event cancellation insurance with the $500,000 advanced granted by Shumenov. GTP’s failure to do so was not discovered until Braehmer pulled out of the fight.

In order to prevail on the claim for breach of contract and achieve declaratory judgment Shumenov must prove that the breach was material to the core of the agreement and served to devastate the value of the contract, thus entitling him to force GTP to provide specific performance of the agreement or money damages and termination of the contract. Shumenov is requesting money damages and attorneys fees. The cause of action for the breach is based on numerous claims which include the following:

(1) “GTP failed to perform under the Promotional Agreement and subsequent related agreements in connection with the promotion of Shumenov in accordance with their terms and materially below industry standards and customary practices with respect to the performance of the duties of a promoter for boxing matches and with respect to Shumenov’s career.”

(2) “GTP failed to arrange for bouts and bear the expenses of the bouts, entered into bout agreements contrary to the terms of the Promotional Agreement (and governing jurisdictions) and related agreements, violated express agreements between Shumenov and GTP, caused Shumenov to pay taxes and sanctioning fees on phantom purses and failed to promote the bouts in any reasonable fashion (and well below the contractual promise to promote “first class boxing matches”). GTP has further failed to make good-faith offers of bouts, failed to perform its promise that it would procure HBO or Showtime for his bouts after a defeat of Uzelkov and cannot meet the contractual requirement of promoting two bouts per year under the Promotional Agreement.”

(3) “GTP has also breached its contractual obligations by, without limitation, failing to properly account for the $500,000 advanced towards the failed Braehmer bout, failing to return all of the funds advanced, making improper expense charges against those advanced funds, failing to timely pay purses and failing to procure event cancellation insurance.”

(4) “GTP’s actions and inactions in performance of the Promotion Agreement are further a breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing implied into every contract. GTP has acted and failed to act in deliberate contravention of the purpose and spirit of the Promotion Agreement and thwarted the justified expectations of Shumenov under the Promotional Agreement and subsequent related agreements.”

(5) “GTP has further failed to honor its promise to rescind the Promotional Agreement and walk away if Shumenov became dissatisfied with GTP.”

If the breach is found to be minor as opposed to material, then GTP may still retain the contract as valid but be required to provide full performance or actual damages for the breach. Shumenov may still be liable for the remainder of the agreement if the breach was not material.

The second claim is for breach of fiduciary duty, which by definition is an obligation to act in the best interest of another party. There should be no contention that a fiduciary duty was in fact owed. The court will serve to determine whether GTP’s actions were motivated by another interest not beneficial to Shumenov. Shumenov asserts that not only was the fiduciary duty breached, but it was done willfully and maliciously giving rise to the claim of fraud. To succeed on the fraud claim Shumenov must prove that GTP made a misrepresentation of a material fact. Shumenov asserts that GTP made many misrepresentations including GTP’s capability of securing opponents and broadcasting contract. A claim of fraud also entitles Shumenov to request punitive damages, which he has.

In an interview with ESPN Sports, promoter Dan Goossen stated, “We have a valid and enforceable contract and will pursue our legal rights, and have formally informed Shumenov, advising him of that.”

Attorneys for GTP are likely already at work on a “motion to dismiss,” which is a fairly standard first line of defense. To succeed, the GTP must show that the claims asserted by Shumenov have no merit and therefore no remedy for recovery. This motion may be followed by a response and so forth as litigation ping pong goes. There is no way to tell how quickly the Clark County District Court docket is moving, but in the mean time Shumenov will likely proceed with his career as if the contract is void since the court decision will be necessary to prove its enforceability.

“We hope Goossen Tutor will correctly assess the situation and step aside. If no, the lawsuit will be vigorously pursued on our part until resolution by the Court,” commented Cary Redlin of KZ Event Productions to BoxingInsider.com on behalf of KZ and Beibut Shumenov, “Beibut greatly appreciates the support of his fans and looks forward to fighting again in the near future. He will continue to pursue his quest to unify the light-heavyweight titles and considers his disputes with GTP just one more obstacle he will overcome.”

Bryanna Fissori is BoxingInsider.com’s legal analyst.

767 Comments

  2. drover sointeru
    11/04/2024,

    Fantastic site. Plenty of useful info here. I’m sending it to some friends ans also sharing in delicious. And naturally, thanks for your sweat!

  3. 9 carat diamond price
    11/18/2024,

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More on on that Topic: boxinginsider.com/columns/legal-analysis-beibut-shumenov-v-goossen-tutor-breach-of-contract/ […]

  5. genie168
    01/25/2025,

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More here to that Topic: boxinginsider.com/columns/legal-analysis-beibut-shumenov-v-goossen-tutor-breach-of-contract/ […]

  7. Aviator
    02/21/2025,

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More on on that Topic: boxinginsider.com/columns/legal-analysis-beibut-shumenov-v-goossen-tutor-breach-of-contract/ […]

  10. LorenzoPhoft
    03/17/2025,

    Their global health initiatives are game-changers.
    out of date gabapentin
    Always a seamless experience, whether ordering domestically or internationally.

  25. MonteEduct
    03/25/2025,

    lowest prescription prices online india India Med Fast india online pharmacy store

  40. Freshbet
    03/26/2025,

    … [Trackback]

    […] Here you will find 24475 more Information to that Topic: boxinginsider.com/columns/legal-analysis-beibut-shumenov-v-goossen-tutor-breach-of-contract/ […]

  146. DanielGlots
    04/08/2025,

    lisinopril price without insurance: Lisin Express – lisinopril 5 mg tablet price

  154. Robertglarp
    04/09/2025,

    en Г§ok kazandД±ran casino sitesi: casibom – slot bonus casibom1st.com

  155. WeldonCob
    04/09/2025,

    en az para yatД±rД±lan bahis siteleri: casibom 1st – casinonaxi casibom1st.com

  175. Micahpax
    04/12/2025,

    Mexican pharmacy ship to USA: UsMex Pharm – Mexican pharmacy ship to USA

  240. VictorDeers
    04/21/2025,

    olympe casino cresus: olympe – olympe casino en ligne

  257. BillieRef
    04/24/2025,

    Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable: pharmacie en ligne – pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique pharmafst.com

  260. Bradleyeages
    04/24/2025,

    pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne – acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance pharmafst.com

  269. Bernardactit
    04/25/2025,

    Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable: Livraison rapide – vente de mГ©dicament en ligne pharmafst.com

  276. BillieRef
    04/26/2025,

    Cialis sans ordonnance pas cher: cialis prix – cialis prix tadalmed.shop

  277. Bernardactit
    04/26/2025,

    pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: Livraison rapide – pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es pharmafst.com

  285. Bernardactit
    04/27/2025,

    Achat Cialis en ligne fiable: Cialis en ligne – Tadalafil sans ordonnance en ligne tadalmed.shop

  319. ElmerDaw
    04/30/2025,

    вавада официальный сайт: vavada casino – vavada вход

  322. RichardSmatt
    04/30/2025,

    вавада казино vavada вавада казино

  329. KennethSnind
    05/01/2025,

    вавада зеркало: vavada casino – вавада официальный сайт

  338. ElmerDaw
    05/02/2025,

    вавада официальный сайт: vavada – vavada вход

  371. KennethSnind
    05/07/2025,

    вавада зеркало: vavada – вавада

  428. MatthewHacle
    05/13/2025,

    can i purchase clomid tablets [url=http://clomhealth.com/#]Clom Health[/url] order cheap clomid now

  431. RussellEdups
    05/13/2025,

    how to buy cheap clomid now: clomid cost – buy generic clomid pill

  442. LorenBonee
    05/15/2025,

    cialis 800 black canada: TadalAccess – how much does cialis cost per pill

  459. LorenBonee
    05/17/2025,

    sildenafil vs tadalafil vs vardenafil: TadalAccess – cialis free trial offer

  462. LorenBonee
    05/17/2025,

    tadalafil (tadalis-ajanta): TadalAccess – side effects of cialis daily

  464. JosephLaf
    05/17/2025,

    difference between sildenafil and tadalafil TadalAccess cialis not working anymore

  466. LorenBonee
    05/18/2025,

    max dosage of cialis: TadalAccess – canadian pharmacy cialis 20mg

  471. LorenBonee
    05/18/2025,

    can i take two 5mg cialis at once: cialis headache – how long for cialis to take effect

  475. LorenBonee
    05/19/2025,

    sanofi cialis otc: TadalAccess – compounded tadalafil troche life span

  480. ScottCug
    05/19/2025,

    when is the best time to take cialis: Tadal Access – cialis 20 mg price walmart

  485. LorenBonee
    05/20/2025,

    can i take two 5mg cialis at once: TadalAccess – cialis sublingual

  486. JosephLaf
    05/20/2025,

    best place to buy tadalafil online TadalAccess what is the cost of cialis

  491. LorenBonee
    05/21/2025,

    cialis 5mg daily how long before it works: Tadal Access – cialis pills pictures

  497. LorenBonee
    05/22/2025,

    cialis without a doctor prescription canada: Tadal Access – cialis where to buy in las vegas nv

  498. JosephLaf
    05/22/2025,

    blue sky peptide tadalafil review TadalAccess generic tadalafil prices

  505. LorenBonee
    05/23/2025,

    what does cialis treat: Tadal Access – when is the best time to take cialis

  506. JosephLaf
    05/23/2025,

    cialis tadalafil 20mg kaufen Tadal Access when is generic cialis available

  511. JosephMom
    05/27/2025,

    buy antibiotics over the counter: BiotPharm – get antibiotics without seeing a doctor

  525. JosephMom
    05/29/2025,

    buy antibiotics from canada: Biot Pharm – Over the counter antibiotics for infection

  531. Curtisfline
    05/29/2025,

    Licensed online pharmacy AU: PharmAu24 – Discount pharmacy Australia

  536. Curtisfline
    05/29/2025,

    best online doctor for antibiotics: BiotPharm – get antibiotics without seeing a doctor

  574. Eugeneinsup
    05/31/2025,

    pharmacie en ligne france pas cher kamagra gel acheter Kamagra sans ordonnance

  580. Issacfum
    06/01/2025,

    commander Cialis en ligne sans prescription: Acheter Cialis – pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique

  590. WilliamSkaws
    06/02/2025,

    farmacia italiana online con pagamento alla consegna: menaderm crema – vardenafil 20mg

  606. JosephThymn
    06/03/2025,

    senshio 60 mg vendita online: parvati 10/5 – immunoprofilassi anti-d prezzo

  614. BradleyBrack
    06/03/2025,

    acheter pilule pharmacie sans ordonnance tetine avent natural peut on acheter du viagra sans ordonnance en pharmacie

  618. Michaelcroda
    06/03/2025,

    peut on acheter du viagra en pharmacie sans ordonnance en france: ozempic sans ordonnance – mГ©dicament pour la prostate sans ordonnance

  619. BradleyBrack
    06/03/2025,

    zithromax sans ordonnance en pharmacie ideal soleil viagra achat en ligne

  621. BradleyBrack
    06/04/2025,

    tadalafil 5mg boГ®te 28 prix Pharmacie Express peut on avoir de la ventoline en pharmacie sans ordonnance

  642. Charlesjex
    06/05/2025,

    pharmacy india online: InPharm24 – divya pharmacy india

  647. RandallLurnE
    06/05/2025,

    cancun pharmacy: Pharm Mex – mexican pharmacy houston

  651. RandallLurnE
    06/05/2025,

    ozempic india pharmacy: InPharm24 – best online pharmacy in india

  654. RandallLurnE
    06/05/2025,

    mexico pharmacy online: Pharm Mex – best drugs to buy in mexico

  663. Rogernuh
    06/06/2025,

    generic cialis india pharmacy: InPharm24 – pharmacies in india

  678. Briancep
    06/07/2025,

    buy female viagra usa: VGR Sources – can i buy viagra over the counter in usa

  690. BrandonHom
    06/08/2025,

    best over the counter viagra pill VGR Sources where can i get viagra prescription

  698. Jamesstole
    06/08/2025,

    generic viagra 100mg online: VGR Sources – where can i order real viagra

  700. BrandonHom
    06/08/2025,

    how can i get viagra over the counter VGR Sources where can you buy viagra pills

  703. Billyphone
    06/09/2025,

    buy real sildenafil online with paypal from india: VGR Sources – viagra price without insurance

  709. Briancep
    06/09/2025,

    sildenafil order without prescription: VGR Sources – average price of viagra

  711. Jamesstole
    06/09/2025,

    viagra online purchase india: VGR Sources – us online pharmacy viagra

  716. Briancep
    06/09/2025,

    viagra 50 mg for sale: VGR Sources – sildenafil prescription discount

  732. EstebanInage
    06/10/2025,

    Safe online pharmacy for Crestor: CrestorPharm – side effects crestor rosuvastatin

  733. Alfonsodiz
    06/10/2025,

    what happens if you take too much lipitor: Lipi Pharm – Cheap Lipitor 10mg / 20mg / 40mg

  738. BillyTah
    06/11/2025,

    pictures of atorvastatin 10 mg: LipiPharm – Cheap Lipitor 10mg / 20mg / 40mg

  739. Alfonsodiz
    06/11/2025,

    prednisone 0.5 mg: PredniPharm – over the counter prednisone pills

  748. AlbertoKit
    06/11/2025,

    can lipitor make you gain weight LipiPharm coq10 and lipitor

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *