Boxing Judges, Not Jurors

560

By Barry Lindenman

We are called judges. We are not jurors. Fights that go to a decision are decided by judges, not jurors. What is meant by that is that the winner of a fight is determined by the scores of the majority of the three judges sitting at ringside. Boxing decisions, unlike a jury trial, do not have to be unanimous in order to be rendered. Even the judges sitting on the Supreme Court of the United States of America arrive at decisions and determine the legality of the law by “split decisions.”

It would be great if all boxing decisions were unanimous and that the opinions of all three judges sitting at ringside were exactly the same. The reality however, is that that is rarely the case. The reasons for this are many: different views of the fight due to the differing vantage points that the three judges have; preferences of a certain “style” of fighter over another (i.e. a boxer landing the greater quantity of blows vs. a puncher who is landing the more powerful blows); and sadly, some judges are wrongly influenced by external factors that should not come into play when scoring a round (i.e. the “hometown” fighter, who the champion is, crowd reaction, etc.)

The key to judging a fight (and by that I mean scoring a round) is both simple and complex at the same time. It’s simple from the perspective of that you literally have the best seat in the house and are able to see, hear and observe all the activity occurring in the ring up close and personal . The complex part (it appears) is the ability to focus and concentrate for the full three minutes of each round while at the same time blocking out all extraneous factors that shouldn’t affect the scoring of a round.

For me at least, the process of focus and concentration begins well before the fight starts. It involves adequately preparing myself for the task at hand. A boxing judge needs to prepare himself for a fight just as a fighter does, both physically and mentally. If a judge’s head is not thoroughly into his or her role as the round starts, they won’t be able to completely focus and concentrate on what he or she is supposed to do.

Unfortunately, for a variety of reasons, the public’s current trust in boxing judges as on par with their trust in politicians and Florida jurors (i.e. the Casey Anthony trial). Perhaps boxing judges should be treated more like jurors sitting on a jury. Jurors can be removed for various indiscretions and replaced by an “alternate juror.” Now there’s a possible idea: why not have an additional judge at ringside who also scores each round as well (albeit “unofficially” unless there is a need for them). If one of the “official” judge’s scores is way off the mark, perhaps it can be discarded and replaced, if you will, by the score of the fourth “unofficial” judge. There are four sides to a boxing ring. Why not simply add a fourth judge into the mix so that an additional 25% of observation coverage can be added ?

When you get right to it, a boxing match is very similar to a court trial. There are two sides both wanting to win; there is usually only one winner (except in cases of a draw or a hung jury); the winner is decided by a vote of the presiding officials (judges or jurors). The biggest difference that I see is that the winner of a boxing match doesn’t have to be decided by a unanimous vote of the judges, currently a simple majority will do. Is that something that should change? If we made a boxing match more like a jury trial so that all decisions would have to be unanimous in order to be considered official, would that give more credibility to our sport and to boxing officials specifically? Remember, boxing officials are called judges. Should we change that so that we become “boxing jurors?”

Barry Lindenman can be reached at [email protected]

560 Comments

  3. DouglaseVamy
    01/24/2025,

    I’ve started using CBD gummies like https://www.cornbreadhemp.com/products/thc-gummies-10mg , and they’ve made a perceptible contrast in my routine. They’re easygoing to use, palate monstrous, and accommodate a unembellished way to mix CBD into my day. I’ve originate they help me decrease and improve my siesta after a prolonged period, which has been a stupendous benefit. The accordant CBD dosage in each gummy is a big plus looking for managing intake. If you’re considering CBD, gummies are an remarkable choice to start with—just draw up sure you select a faithful disgrace in regard to the most artistically results!

  41. WilliamDic
    03/27/2025,

    KamagraKopen.pro: Kamagra – Kamagra Kopen Online

  59. luckyet
    03/29/2025,

    … [Trackback]

    […] Find More here to that Topic: boxinginsider.com/columns/boxing-judges-not-jurors/ […]

  99. Chesternig
    04/03/2025,

    canadian online pharmacy reviews: GoCanadaPharm – reliable canadian pharmacy

  158. WeldonCob
    04/09/2025,

    tГјrkiye yasal bahis siteleri: casibom – casino kumar oyunlarД± casibom1st.com

  165. Robertglarp
    04/10/2025,

    casino bonusu veren siteler: casibom resmi – yasal oyun siteleri casibom1st.com

  166. Robertglarp
    04/10/2025,

    en Г§ok freespin veren slot 2025: casibom guncel adres – en gГјvenilir bahis siteleri hangileri? casibom1st.com

  167. BradyAduck
    04/10/2025,

    bonus veren bahis siteleri casino: casibom 1st – deneme bonusu veren siteler 2025 casibom1st.com

  250. VictorDeers
    04/21/2025,

    casino olympe: olympe – olympe casino avis

  257. Gregoryrooks
    04/23/2025,

    olympe casino cresus: olympe – olympe casino

  268. Bradleyeages
    04/24/2025,

    Achat Cialis en ligne fiable: cialis generique – Tadalafil 20 mg prix en pharmacie tadalmed.shop

  292. PeterQuogy
    04/26/2025,

    Cialis sans ordonnance 24h Acheter Cialis Tadalafil sans ordonnance en ligne tadalmed.com

  300. PeterQuogy
    04/27/2025,

    Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable pharmacie en ligne pharmacie en ligne livraison europe pharmafst.shop

  306. Bernardactit
    04/27/2025,

    Tadalafil achat en ligne: cialis prix – Tadalafil 20 mg prix en pharmacie tadalmed.shop

  313. MichaelExhab
    04/28/2025,

    pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: mexican rx online – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa

  341. ElmerDaw
    04/30/2025,

    pin up azerbaycan: pin-up – pin up azerbaycan

  344. KennethSnind
    05/01/2025,

    pin up azerbaycan: pin up – pin up azerbaycan

  355. Brianthigo
    05/02/2025,

    вавада официальный сайт: vavada casino – вавада казино

  361. Brianthigo
    05/02/2025,

    вавада зеркало: vavada вход – вавада официальный сайт

  382. RichardSmatt
    05/04/2025,

    вавада вавада вавада официальный сайт

  388. ElmerDaw
    05/05/2025,

    вавада зеркало: vavada – вавада

  437. RussellEdups
    05/12/2025,

    prednisone over the counter australia: PredniHealth – buy prednisone tablets online

  446. MatthewHacle
    05/13/2025,

    cost of clomid no prescription Clom Health where can i get cheap clomid without dr prescription

  452. JosephLaf
    05/14/2025,

    how long before sex should you take cialis TadalAccess tadalafil hong kong

  457. LorenBonee
    05/14/2025,

    buy cialis no prescription: Tadal Access – is cialis covered by insurance

  460. JosephLaf
    05/15/2025,

    what is cialis tadalafil used for Tadal Access cialis free trial voucher 2018

  465. LorenBonee
    05/15/2025,

    cialis tadalafil 20mg kaufen: Tadal Access – tadalafil (tadalis-ajanta)

  466. ScottCug
    05/15/2025,

    benefits of tadalafil over sidenafil: TadalAccess – what is cialis used for

  469. JosephLaf
    05/15/2025,

    which is better cialis or levitra TadalAccess cialis purchase canada

  471. Jerrysoype
    05/15/2025,

    At pre-eminent, I was skeptical in the matter of https://joyorganics.com/products/organic-cbd-salve , but now I provision them in my nightstand. They’ve develop voice of my evening wont—sole gummy, a cup of tea, and I’m tolerable to go. I don’t feel exorbitant or weird, nothing but stillness and ready to afraid down. The flavor’s absolutely exceptionally fitting too, which surprised me. No unnatural aftertaste like some others I’ve tried. If your leader runs a mile a minute at cimmerian dark or you’re upstanding tough to slacken after at liberty, these are indubitably value checking out.

  488. JosephLaf
    05/18/2025,

    buy cialis no prescription overnight TadalAccess buy generic cialiss

  490. ScottCug
    05/18/2025,

    cialis online canada ripoff: TadalAccess – cialis for sale in toront ontario

  498. LorenBonee
    05/19/2025,

    canada cialis for sale: TadalAccess – canadian pharmacy online cialis

  507. ScottCug
    05/20/2025,

    buy cialis free shipping: Tadal Access – where to buy cialis over the counter

  521. JosephLaf
    05/21/2025,

    san antonio cialis doctor TadalAccess cialis delivery held at customs

  523. JosephLaf
    05/22/2025,

    is tadalafil and cialis the same thing? Tadal Access erectile dysfunction tadalafil

  524. ScottCug
    05/22/2025,

    cialis 100mg from china: TadalAccess – canadian online pharmacy cialis

  529. LorenBonee
    05/23/2025,

    cialis information: Tadal Access – where to buy cialis online for cheap

  536. JosephLaf
    05/24/2025,

    tadalafil canada is it safe Tadal Access cialis super active real online store

  538. Charlesoxive
    05/27/2025,

    Over the counter antibiotics pills: BiotPharm – get antibiotics quickly

  540. JosephMom
    05/27/2025,

    Medications online Australia: Pharm Au24 – Medications online Australia

  548. JosephMom
    05/28/2025,

    best online doctor for antibiotics: BiotPharm – buy antibiotics over the counter

  550. RodneyLog
    05/28/2025,

    Discount pharmacy Australia PharmAu24 Discount pharmacy Australia

  555. bkiodouoh
    06/02/2025,

    Si has jugado a la Sweet Bonanza original, ya sabrás lo que puedes esperar de esta tragaperras desde un punto de vista visual. Los carretes se muestran en el centro de un reino de los dulces, con montañas de malvavisco gigantes y piruletas enormes que crecen del suelo. En los carretes aparecen símbolos de todo tipo de dulces y frutas. For more information please contact Gaming Control Authority of your country. Boyd Gaming is a well-known regional casino operator with 28 properties across ten states, Bayern Munichs elegant style of football will be sure to excite those whove never seen the sport played professionally. This is because bingo is easy to play and it is also a lot of fun, so you can pick and choose the ones that offer you the best winning chances. Each time a wild appears in a free spin, Green Lucky 7. The theme on the screen and the reels of the slot is fully disclosed that confirms the feeling of participation in the dangerous adventures, Triple BAR.
    https://12jeet.co/resena-del-juego-balloon-de-smartsoft-diversion-aerea-en-casinos-online-colombianos/
    As combinações maduro formadas por clusters com a possibilidade infantilidade achegar significativamente briga demasia pressuroso prêmio em uma rodada. Arruíi slot Sweet Bonanza tem recursos criancice bônus na forma puerilidade Scatter, rodadas acostumado, novas rodadas, multiplicadores. Os jogadores fazem uma demora algum en-sejo que querem aprestar, pagando por uma rodada dos demanda-níqueis. Como fan de las tragaperras, descubrir las mejores versiones de Sweet Bonanza ha sido una grata sorpresa. PlayUZU ofrece la versión navideña y el exclusivo Sweet Bonanza 1000, con recompensas de hasta 25.000 veces tu apuesta. Además, también está disponible la versión Slingo que no te puedes perder. Spela Online Och Vinn Stora Vinster Idag! Content Hur Guy Börjar Spela Plinko Sverige Var Har Mulighed For Jag Spela Plinko Gratis? Nine Casino Fördelarna Med Att Lyckas Spela Plinko Online Topp 6 Mest Populära Plinko Game Casino Plinko – Ett Populärt Spel I Living Area Nya Eran Utav Onlinekasinon Utnyttja Bonusar Och Erbjudanden Hur … Leer más

  556. skcebmtud
    06/07/2025,

    Make it easy for your players to enjoy the world’s favourite Live Casino games! Flag any particular issues you may encounter and Softonic will address those concerns as soon as possible. From VIP hosts to native-speaking dealers, create a unique online Live Casino tailored to your specifications. 91 Club | Tiranga | Tc Lottery Discover Evolution’s dedicated tables and environments, where your brand takes centre stage. Immerse yourself in a world of limitless customisation and branding options, offering total control over player experiences, betting limits, and special promotions. Download APK on Android with Free Online APK Downloader – APKPure It means a benign program is wrongfully flagged as malicious due to an overly broad detection signature or algorithm used in an antivirus program.
    https://hb-themes.com/forum/all/users/camphysasapp1976/
    We maintain segregated accounts for our players. We do this for security and to fulfil our monetary obligations towards you upon winning. All personal and financial information provided is held completely confidential. Dragon Tiger Slots – Up Down, developed by MayLyn55, is a free card game that blends the anticipation of slot machines with the strategic element of card games. The app leverages the best of these two worlds to transform the traditional card game experience into an exciting adventure full of unique challenges. Dragon vs Tiger is a variation of Teen Patti where players bet on which of two cards, the Dragon or the Tiger, will be higher. According to the Bangalore High Court, this game is considered as a game of skill in India, but it is more fun and entertaining than anything else. At first glance, the game may seem purely based on luck, but that would be like underestimating the amount of time, effort, and practice that players put in. The dedication of a player focuses on perfecting skills like bankroll management, reading the room, knowing when to fold, and so on.

  557. cnngnmcom
    06/14/2025,

    A few differences exist between the real money and demo versions of Aviator. I will offer up one piece of extra advice here, though. Don’t lean too much on the strategies other players use in the demo version of Aviator. Players aren’t often as cautious in this version as in the real money game because they use fake money for their bets. Aviator is an exciting crash game developed by Spribe. The primary objective for players is to cash out their winnings before the plane flies off the screen. The game is available on the website Aviator Game and supports various devices including desktop and mobile platforms. Here’s a detailed overview of the game rules, mechanics, and features: We offer our players the best Android casino apps. Gamers and entertainment enthusiasts may now access the online casino via an online casino in Bangladesh app and a mobile version. The Pin Up casino mobile version of the best online casino in Bangladesh offers complete functionality and is as easy to navigate as possible. You need to use a smartphone or tablet to open the Pin Up mobile version, enter your profile, and use all the features. The benefits include a modified look and the option to play for real money whenever and wherever you choose.
    https://cgmood.com/craig-dee
    Space XY is an exciting crash game from BGaming that offers players an excellent chance to win huge prizes. You can learn everything you need to know about this thrilling specialty game by reading the free guide above. Like other crash rocket games, Space XY has an outer space theme and setting. The graphics, animations, and sound effects are of high quality overall. I’ve been playing Space XY for about half a year now, and although the game is new, it’s very exciting. I like that it has added arcade elements, which makes the gameplay more interesting. Winning every time is quite difficult, so I always bet over 0. Once I even won 5000 thanks to such a bet! Do not forget that if your intuition fails you and you do not have time to collect the money before the Rocket leaves the game, then the bet funds will burn out. Space XY is a great way to have fun, tickle your nerves and win by expanding your wallet!

  559. mwedqfmhi
    06/19/2025,

    E as funções? Não vem achando que é só girar e rezar. Aqui tem avalanche de símbolos, wilds dançantes, respins que viram jogos bônus, e até mecânicas malucas de escolha que parecem videogame de escolha múltipla. Tem slot com progressivo. Tem multiplicador que vai subindo. Tem recurso que você nem entende, mas sorri porque a tela tá explodindo em luzes. Antes de escolher onde jogar no Fortune Tiger é importante conferir se o cassino escolhido é confiável. Para isso, confira se o site possui a licença necessária para atuar no Brasil e traz métodos de pagamento permitidos pela lei federal (como Pix ou Transferência Bancária). Ainda, entenda se a plataforma traz regras de Jogo Responsável e um cassino seguro com criptografia de ponta a ponta.
    https://jszst.com.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=5782712
    Se você aprecia a experiência de jogo com Fortune Tiger, talvez também esteja interessado em outros jogos cativantes da PG Soft. Descubra as aventuras únicas e os gráficos ricos de Fortune Rabbit e Fortune Mouse, duas outras máquinas caça-níqueis que prometem uma experiência de jogo emocionante e lucrativa. O jogo Fortune Tiger oferece vantagens, como multiplicadores de até 10x e gráficos impressionantes. No entanto, também apresenta desvantagens, incluindo um número limitado de linhas de pagamento e a ausência de recursos adicionais, como rodadas grátis ou jogos bônus.5. Como ativar a rodada turbo no Fortune Tiger?A rodada Turbo é uma função do Jogo do Tigre que acelera as rodadas e pode ser ativada pelo símbolo do Raio no canto inferior esquerdo do jogo. Alguns dos principais cassinos online que pagam ao jogar Fortune Tiger são os seguintes: Superbet, VBET, Novibet, Betnacional, KTO e bet365.

  560. xzzhzzhlu
    06/27/2025,

    Hej, jag hörde inte den frågan eller så kanske det är något annat de menar. Betyder det inte något som att du inte kommer från ett begränsat land eller något liknande? ✅ MyCasinoIndex har skapat en ranking av onlinekasinon med Pragmatic Play slots. Utforska de högst rankade verifierade kasinon med spelautomaten Sweet Bonanza Xmas. Spin Sweet Casino är ett sprillans nytt casino av väletablerade Elmst Limited som har sin licens på Malta med registreringsnummer C98783 och erbjuder instant banking casino. här bjud spelare på hela 7777st free spins och €1500 i casino bonusar uppdelat på de fyra första insättningarna. Som utlandssvenskar har vi tagit oss friheten att testa och recensera Spin Sweet casino! Låt oss till exempel säga att din freespins bonus har ett totalt värde på 500 kronor och ett omsättningskrav på 6x. Då räknar du ut hur mycket du behöver spela igenom genom att multiplicera värdet på bonusen med omsättningskravet. I detta fallet är det 500 kr * 6, alltså 3000. Detta innebär att du måste spela igenom 3000 kronor innan du kan vinna något annat än spelpengar. När du mött omsättningskravet kan du ta ut din vinst.
    https://www.hakshackwoodworks.com/forum/general-discussions/create-post
    Nordicbet är även ett av de casinon som har valt att utveckla en egen mobilapp. Du kan ladda ner denna helt kostnadsfritt från Play Store eller App Store och ta del av hela utbudet. Sök bara efter ”nordicbet app” så brukar den dyka upp. Vi tycker definitivt att Sweet Bonanza Slot är ett spel som du ska ge en chans. Om du föredrar välgjorda och lite mer lekfulla teman kommer du inte att bli besviken. En maxvinst på 21175 gånger insatsen bidrar ytterligare till spänningen! För att spela Betsafe mobilcasino kan vi rekommendera appen som går att ladda ner från casinots webbplats (som skickar dig vidare till App store eller Google Play store beroende på om du har en iOS eller Android-enhet). Nordicbet är även ett av de casinon som har valt att utveckla en egen mobilapp. Du kan ladda ner denna helt kostnadsfritt från Play Store eller App Store och ta del av hela utbudet. Sök bara efter ”nordicbet app” så brukar den dyka upp.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *